Learn on PengiPengi Social Studies (Grade 8)Chapter 9: The Progressive Era and America as a World Power (1890–1917)

Lesson 2: Conservation and the Environment

In this Grade 8 lesson from Pengi Social Studies, students examine the influential relationship between Theodore Roosevelt and John Muir and its role in shaping early environmental policy. Using the Hetch Hetchy Valley debate as a case study, students analyze the key distinctions between preservation and conservation as competing philosophies during the Progressive Era.

Section 1

The President and the Naturalist

President Theodore Roosevelt was a passionate outdoorsman who made protecting nature a central goal of his presidency. In 1903, he went on a legendary camping trip in Yosemite with the naturalist John Muir. During their time in the wilderness, Muir convinced the President that the federal government had a moral duty to protect America's natural wonders from destruction.

This partnership changed the American landscape forever. Inspired by Muir, Roosevelt set aside millions of acres of forests and monuments. Their collaboration laid the essential groundwork for the creation of the National Park Service in 1916, an agency dedicated to conserving scenery and wildlife for the enjoyment of future generations.

Section 2

The Hetch Hetchy Controversy

While Progressives agreed nature mattered, they debated how to handle it. Preservationists like John Muir believed wilderness should be left untouched for spiritual renewal. In contrast, Conservationists like Gifford Pinchot (head of the U.S. Forest Service) believed natural resources should be managed scientifically and used for the "greatest good for the greatest number."

This conflict exploded over the Hetch Hetchy Valley in California. The city of San Francisco wanted to dam the valley to create a water reservoir. Muir fought to save the valley, while Pinchot supported the dam as a public necessity. Congress eventually approved the dam, a bitter defeat for preservationists, but the controversy awakened the nation to the importance of environmental protection.

Book overview

Jump across lessons in the current chapter without opening the full course modal.

Continue this chapter

Chapter 9: The Progressive Era and America as a World Power (1890–1917)

  1. Lesson 1

    Lesson 1: The Progressive Response to Social Problems

  2. Lesson 2Current

    Lesson 2: Conservation and the Environment

  3. Lesson 3

    Lesson 3: The United States Becomes a World Power

Lesson overview

Expand to review the lesson summary and core properties.

Expand

Section 1

The President and the Naturalist

President Theodore Roosevelt was a passionate outdoorsman who made protecting nature a central goal of his presidency. In 1903, he went on a legendary camping trip in Yosemite with the naturalist John Muir. During their time in the wilderness, Muir convinced the President that the federal government had a moral duty to protect America's natural wonders from destruction.

This partnership changed the American landscape forever. Inspired by Muir, Roosevelt set aside millions of acres of forests and monuments. Their collaboration laid the essential groundwork for the creation of the National Park Service in 1916, an agency dedicated to conserving scenery and wildlife for the enjoyment of future generations.

Section 2

The Hetch Hetchy Controversy

While Progressives agreed nature mattered, they debated how to handle it. Preservationists like John Muir believed wilderness should be left untouched for spiritual renewal. In contrast, Conservationists like Gifford Pinchot (head of the U.S. Forest Service) believed natural resources should be managed scientifically and used for the "greatest good for the greatest number."

This conflict exploded over the Hetch Hetchy Valley in California. The city of San Francisco wanted to dam the valley to create a water reservoir. Muir fought to save the valley, while Pinchot supported the dam as a public necessity. Congress eventually approved the dam, a bitter defeat for preservationists, but the controversy awakened the nation to the importance of environmental protection.

Book overview

Jump across lessons in the current chapter without opening the full course modal.

Continue this chapter

Chapter 9: The Progressive Era and America as a World Power (1890–1917)

  1. Lesson 1

    Lesson 1: The Progressive Response to Social Problems

  2. Lesson 2Current

    Lesson 2: Conservation and the Environment

  3. Lesson 3

    Lesson 3: The United States Becomes a World Power